Refine your search

Keyword:

Grounds:

Show more

Year:

Country:

Show more

Article(s):

Show more

Order:

Show more

Requesting State:

Show more

Requested State:

Show more

Court Level:

Show more

Instrument:

Search results (1632)

  • 2024 | HC/E/UY 1683 | URUGUAY | Appellate Court
    Languages
    Full text download ES
    Summary available in ES
    Grounds

    Grave Risk - Art. 13(1)(b) | Objections of the Child to a Return - Art. 13(2) | Best Interests of the Child | Settlement of the Child - Art. 12(2)

    Order

    Appeal allowed, return ordered

    Article(s)

    13(1)(b) 13(2) 12(2)

  • 2020 | HC/E/JP 1558 | JAPAN | Superior Appellate Court
    Languages
    Full text download EN
    Summary available in EN | ES
    Grounds

    Issues Relating to Return

    Order

    Case remitted to lower court

    Article(s)

    3

    Synopsis

    Child born in 2006 in Russia ― Father a Russian national, mother a Japanese national ― Married parents living in Moscow from 2007 and later divorced ― Mother retained the child aged nine years in Japan in August 2016 ― Father filed petition for the child’s return in Japanese courts in November 2016 ― Parents agreed on the child’s return, child support and access etc. in conciliation ― Child refused to return ― Father further sought a habeas corpus order ― Parents concluded a judicial settlement ― Mother petitioned for annulment of the return clause reached in conciliation ― Main issue: procedural issues, modification of a return clause made in conciliation.

  • 2022 | HC/E/JP 1629 | JAPAN | Superior Appellate Court
    Languages
    Full text download EN | JA
    Summary available in EN
    Grounds

    Issues Relating to Return

    Order

    Appeal allowed, application dismissed

    Article(s)

    17

    Synopsis

    The parents and the children resided in France ― After the parents’ separation, the father removed two children from France to Japan ― Osaka Family Court ordered the return of the children to France on 11 September 2020, which became final and conclusive on 9 December 2020 ― Divorce decree rendered in France on 23 November 2020 ordered joint custody of the parents and the children to reside with the father in Japan, while only granting visitation right to the mother ― The Osaka Family Court granted the mother’s claim for indirect compulsory execution on 1 February 2021 ― The Osaka High Court reversed the decision and dismissed the mother’s claim to honor the French custody decision on 14 April 2021 ― The Supreme Court upheld the decision on the grounds that the mother’s claim for indirect compulsory execution became unlawful after the children returned to France as a result of compulsory execution by substitute ― Two justices concurred and opined that the lower court decision may conflict with Art. 17 of the 1980 Convention  Main issue: Admissibility of indirect compulsory execution that runs counter to a foreign custody order.

  • 2024 | HC/E/BR 1654 | BRAZIL | Superior Appellate Court
    Languages
    Full text download PT
    Summary available in EN | ES
    Grounds

    Habitual Residence - Art. 3 | Rights of Custody - Art. 3 | Settlement of the Child - Art. 12(2) | Acquiescence - Art. 13(1)(a) | Grave Risk - Art. 13(1)(b)

    Order

    Appeal allowed, return ordered

    Article(s)

    3 12 13(1)(a) 13(1)(b)

    Synopsis

    Wrongful removal of a seven-month-old child – U.S. national – Married parents – Father a U.S. citizen – Mother a Brazilian citizen – Shared rights of custody – Child lived in the United States from birth until May 2021 – Return application submitted to the Central Authority in the United States in September 2021 – Appeal allowed, return ordered – Key issues: habitual residence, rights of custody, settlement of the child, grave risk exception – The child’s habitual residence was in the United States – Custody matters must be resolved by the courts of the State of the child’s habitual residence – The father filed the return application within one year of the wrongful retention – The Court held that the allegations of domestic violence were not substantiated, and that neither the child’s separation from the taking parent nor the immigration obstacles faced by the mother were sufficient to establish the grave risk exception.

  • 2019 | HC/E/MX 1709 | MEXICO | Superior Appellate Court
    Languages
    Full text download ES
    Summary available in ES
    Grounds

    Acquiescence - Art. 13(1)(a) | Objections of the Child to a Return - Art. 13(2) | Best Interests of the Child

    Order

    Application dismissed

    Article(s)

    13(1)(a) 13(2)

  • 2000 | HC/E/RO 336 | European Court of Human Rights (ECrtHR) |
    Languages
    Full text download FR
    Summary available in EN | FR | ES
    Grounds

    Issues Relating to Return

    Ruling

    By a majority of 6 to 1 the Court ruled that Romania had breached Article 8 of the ECHR in failing to take proper steps to enforce the various orders giving the applicant mother care of the girls, in particular the return order of 14 December 1994. The Court also made an award of compensation to the mother under Article 41 of the ECHR.

  • 1999 | HC/E/UKs 352 | UNITED KINGDOM - SCOTLAND | First Instance |
    Languages
    Full text download EN
    Summary available in EN | FR | ES
    Grounds

    Issues Relating to Return | Grave Risk - Art. 13(1)(b) | Undertakings

    Order

    Return ordered with undertakings offered

    Article(s)

    13(1)(b)

    Ruling

    Removal wrongful and return ordered with undertakings offered; the standard of harm required under Article 13(1)(b) had not been made out.

  • 1992 | HC/E/AT 564 | AUSTRIA | Superior Appellate Court |
    Languages
    Full text download DE
    Summary available in EN | FR
    Grounds

    Issues Relating to Return

    Article(s)

    13(1)(b) 13(2)

    Ruling

    Appeal dismissed; the decision ordering return must be enforced. The father had not provided any new elements to justify not enforcing the return order.

  • 2023 | HC/E/UKe 1598 | UNITED KINGDOM - ENGLAND AND WALES | Appellate Court
    Languages
    Full text download EN
    Summary available in EN
    Grounds

    Grave Risk - Art. 13(1)(b) | Non-Convention Issues

    Order

    Appeal allowed, return refused

    Article(s)

    11 13(1)(b)

    Synopsis

    One child wrongfully retained at age 3 - Dual British-American national - Parents married in 2018 but separated in 2023 -  Father American national - Mother British national - Family lived in Texas, USA until mother wrongfully retained child in UK in February 2023 - Father applied for return in England on 22 June 2023 - Return ordered by consent - Mother appealed this based on a lack of consent and absence of protective measures in light of alleged abuse - Main issues: grave risk (Article 13(1)(b) and protective measures; Lack of proper consent - Court found the protective measures were ineffective and not enforceable in Texas, and absence of agreement - Appeal allowed, return refused, and case remitted to lower court.

  • 2020 | HC/E/DE 1470 | GERMANY | Appellate Court
    Languages
    Full text download DE | EN
    Summary available in EN
    Grounds

    Issues Relating to Return | Grave Risk - Art. 13(1)(b)

    Order

    Appeal dismissed, return ordered

    Article(s)

    13(1)(b)

    Ruling

    The court rejected the mother’s application to have the use of direct force in enforcement suspended.

  • 2021 | HC/E/AR 1548 | ARGENTINA | Superior Appellate Court
    Languages
    Full text download
    Summary available in EN | ES
    Grounds

    Removal and Retention - Arts 3 and 12 | Grave Risk - Art. 13(1)(b) | Objections of the Child to a Return - Art. 13(2) | Issues Relating to Return

    Order

    Appeal allowed, return ordered

    Article(s)

    3 12 13(1)(b) 13(2) 15

    Synopsis

    Wrongful removal of two girls when they were 10 and 6 years old – Married parents – The girls lived in Spain until July 2016 – Appeal allowed, return ordered – Main issues: Removal and retention, Art. 13(1)(b) grave risk exception, objections of the child to a return, matters relating to return – There was no concluding evidence that the mother had consented to a change in the girls’ habitual residence to Argentina – There was no grave risk that returning to Spain would cause psychological or physical harm to the girls – The girls did not strongly resist against or oppose returning to Spain, they only stated a mere preference for continuing to live in Argentina – The circumstances of the case had to be taken into account and the COVID-19 health emergency context as well in order to make return immediate and safe.

  • 2021 | HC/E/FR 1726 | FRANCE | Superior Appellate Court
    Languages
    Full text download FR
    Summary available in EN
    Grounds

    Grave Risk - Art. 13(1)(b)

    Order

    Appeal dismissed, return ordered

    Article(s)

    13(1)(b)

    Synopsis

    1 child wrongfully retained at age 7 – Married parents – Both parents had custody over the child – Child lived in Japan until 3 April 2018 – Application for return filed with District Family Court on 27 March 2019 – Return ordered – Main issue: Art. 13(1)(b) – Grave risk: return could cause separation between mother and child (mother raising  immigration issues upon return to Japan and a possible deprivation of her parental rights) - The Supreme Court upheld the Court of Appeal decision to return.

  • 2019 | HC/E/FR 1717 | FRANCE | Superior Appellate Court
    Languages
    Full text download FR
    Summary available in EN
    Grounds

    Grave Risk - Art. 13(1)(b)

    Order

    Appeal dismissed, return refused

    Article(s)

    13(1)(b)

    Synopsis

    3 children wrongfully retained in France – Custody of the children granted to the mother – Children lived in the United States – Mother went with the children to France and refused to return – Application for return filed by the father with the US Central Authority – Request for return filed by the public prosecutor before the court of Paris, France – Court of first instance ordered return - Return refused on appeal – Main issue: Art. 13(1)(b) – Grave risk of harm for the children in case of return in light of the father’s violent conduct and the impossibility for the mother to protect them, due to the arrest warrant issued against her

  • 2025 | HC/E/CL 1655 | CHILE | Superior Appellate Court
    Languages
    Full text download ES
    Summary available in ES
    Grounds

    Removal and Retention - Arts 3 and 12 | Consent - Art. 13(1)(a) | Grave Risk - Art. 13(1)(b) | Objections of the Child to a Return - Art. 13(2) | Jurisdiction Issues - Art. 16 | Best Interests of the Child

    Order

    Appeal dismissed, return ordered

    Article(s)

    3 13(1)(a) 13(1)(b) 13(2)

  • 2022 | HC/E/FR 1718 | FRANCE | Superior Appellate Court
    Languages
    Full text download FR
    Summary available in EN
    Grounds

    Rights of Custody - Art. 3

    Order

    Case remitted to lower court

    Article(s)

    3 5

    Synopsis

    1 child allegedly wrongfully removed at age 7 – Divorced parents – Child lived in Belarus until June 2021 – Application for return filed by the public prosecutor with the District Court of Strasbourg, France, on 27 September 2021 – Case appealed before Court of Appeal of Colmar – Case appealed before Supreme Court - Decision overturned, case remitted to a lower court – Main issue: Article 3 Rights of custody – Court of Appeal should have specified the provisions of the Belarusian law on which it relied to conclude that both parents had rights of custody over the child.

  • 2017 | HC/E/FR 1723 | FRANCE | Superior Appellate Court
    Languages
    Full text download FR
    Summary available in EN
    Grounds

    Grave Risk - Art. 13(1)(b) | Best Interests of the Child

    Order

    Appeal dismissed, return refused

    Article(s)

    13(1)(b)

    Synopsis

    ​​3 children wrongfully retained in France – Children born in 2012, 2013 and 2014 – Nationals of Serbia – Married parents – Both parents had custody rights – Children lived in Serbia until June 2015 – First instance decision ordering the return of the children overturned on appeal – Supreme Court (Cour de Cassation) upheld Court of Appeal decision – Appeal dismissed –  Main issue: Art. 13(1)(b) grave risk exception to return – Father’s conduct and psychological state of the children established grave risk, justifying a non-return order.​ 

  • 2010 | HC/E/ZA 724 | SOUTH AFRICA | First Instance |
    Languages
    No full text available
    Summary available in EN
    Grounds

    Aims of the Convention - Preamble, Arts 1 and 2 | Settlement of the Child - Art. 12(2) | Issues Relating to Return

    Order

    Return ordered

    Article(s)

    12(2)

    Ruling

    Return ordered; the removal was wrongful and none of the exceptions had been established. The Court fixed the conditions for return.

  • 2008 | HC/E/BE 750 | BELGIUM | Superior Appellate Court |
    Languages
    No full text available
    Summary available in FR
    Grounds

    Issues Relating to Return

  • 2003 | HC/E/CA 757 | CANADA | Appellate Court |
    Languages
    Full text download EN
    Summary available in EN | FR | ES
    Grounds

    Grave Risk - Art. 13(1)(b) | Human Rights - Art. 20 | Issues Relating to Return

    Order

    Appeal allowed, return ordered

    Article(s)

    1 2 4 12 13(1)(b)

    Ruling

    Appeal allowed and return ordered, provided that the child was permitted to enter the United States. The retention was wrongful and none of the exceptions had been proved to the standard required by the Convention.

  • 2002 | HC/E/CA 762 | CANADA | Appellate Court |
    Languages
    Full text download EN
    Summary available in EN | FR | ES
    Grounds

    Grave Risk - Art. 13(1)(b) | Undertakings | Issues Relating to Return

    Order

    Appeal allowed, return ordered

    Article(s)

    3 12 13(1)(a) 13(1)(b) 13(2) 13(3)

    Ruling

    Appeal granted and return ordered.