EN
|
FR
|
ES
The Convention
Case Law Analysis
Explanatory Report
Guides to Good Practice
Case Law Search
Legal Instruments
Other Cases
Inter-American Convention cases
Brussels IIa cases
Non-Hague Convention cases
Choose language:
EN
FR
ES
The Convention
Case Law Analysis
Explanatory Report
Guides to Good Practice
Case Law Search
Legal Instruments
Other Cases
Inter-American Convention cases
Brussels IIa cases
Non-Hague Convention cases
Case Law Search
Search criteria may be entered into any or all of the fields.
Search by case name or keyword:
Case ref. no.:
Grounds:
Choose
American Convention on Human Rights (ACHR) (1)
European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) (48)
Inter-American Convention on the International Return of Children (2)
Aims of the Convention - Preamble, Arts 1 and 2 (114)
Habitual Residence - Art. 3 (362)
Removal and Retention - Arts 3 and 12 (161)
Rights of Custody - Art. 3 (352)
Article 15 Decision or Determination (19)
Consent - Art. 13(1)(a) (104)
Acquiescence - Art. 13(1)(a) (149)
Grave Risk - Art. 13(1)(b) (623)
Undertakings (104)
Objections of the Child to a Return - Art. 13(2) (269)
Settlement of the Child - Art. 12(2) (115)
Human Rights - Art. 20 (68)
Issues Relating to Return (89)
Rights of Access - Art. 21 (33)
Role of the Central Authorities - Arts 6 - 10 (18)
Jurisdiction Issues - Art. 16 (20)
Procedural Matters (413)
Interpretation of the Convention (55)
Non-Convention Issues (47)
Legal Doctrine (1)
Brussels IIa Regulation (Council Regulation (EC) No 2201/2003 of 27 November 2003) (28)
Year:
From
2024
2023
2022
2021
2020
2019
2018
2017
2016
2015
2014
2013
2012
2011
2010
2009
2008
2007
2006
2005
2004
2003
2002
2001
2000
1999
1998
1997
1996
1995
1994
1993
1992
1991
1990
1989
1988
1987
1986
To
2024
2023
2022
2021
2020
2019
2018
2017
2016
2015
2014
2013
2012
2011
2010
2009
2008
2007
2006
2005
2004
2003
2002
2001
2000
1999
1998
1997
1996
1995
1994
1993
1992
1991
1990
1989
1988
1987
1986
Country:
Choose
ARGENTINA (14)
AUSTRALIA (75)
AUSTRIA (55)
BELGIUM (17)
BRAZIL (3)
CANADA (104)
CANADA - ALBERTA (1)
CANADA - BRITISH COLUMBIA (7)
CANADA - MANITOBA (4)
CANADA - NEW BRUNSWICK (1)
CANADA - NOVA SCOTIA (1)
CANADA - ONTARIO (12)
CANADA - QUEBEC (3)
CANADA - SASKATCHEWAN (1)
CHILE (3)
CHINA (HONG KONG, SAR) (11)
COLOMBIA (1)
COSTA RICA (3)
CROATIA (5)
CZECH REPUBLIC (1)
DENMARK (17)
DOMINICAN REPUBLIC (2)
ECUADOR (1)
EL SALVADOR (3)
ESTONIA (2)
FINLAND (10)
FRANCE (128)
FRANCE (Reunion) (1)
GEORGIA (4)
GERMANY (53)
GREECE (9)
GUATEMALA (1)
HUNGARY (1)
ICELAND (5)
IRELAND (17)
ISRAEL (45)
ITALY (15)
JAMAICA (1)
JAPAN (18)
KENYA (1)
KOREA, REPUBLIC OF (1)
LITHUANIA (1)
LUXEMBOURG (19)
MALTA (1)
MEXICO (3)
MONACO (1)
NETHERLANDS - KINGDOM IN EUROPE (9)
NEW ZEALAND (57)
NICARAGUA (1)
NORWAY (5)
PAKISTAN (1)
PANAMA (5)
PARAGUAY (2)
PERU (3)
POLAND (2)
PORTUGAL (2)
ROMANIA (1)
RUSSIAN FEDERATION (3)
SAMOA (1)
SINGAPORE (1)
SOUTH AFRICA (21)
SPAIN (9)
SWEDEN (7)
SWITZERLAND (92)
TRINIDAD AND TOBAGO (1)
TURKEY (6)
UKRAINE (1)
UNITED KINGDOM (3)
UNITED KINGDOM - ENGLAND AND WALES (212)
UNITED KINGDOM - NORTHERN IRELAND (13)
UNITED KINGDOM - SCOTLAND (56)
UNITED STATES - FEDERAL JURISDICTION (132)
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA (15)
UNITED STATES - STATE JURISDICTION (34)
URUGUAY (8)
VENEZUELA (1)
ZIMBABWE (1)
Article:
Choose
Preamble (14)
Article 1 (153)
Article 2 (48)
Article 3 (835)
Article 4 (82)
Article 5 (161)
Article 6 (10)
Article 7 (51)
Article 8 (28)
Article 9 (7)
Article 10 (10)
Article 11 (82)
Article 12 (334)
Article 12(1) (34)
Article 12(2) (108)
Article 13(1)(a) (341)
Article 13(1)(b) (758)
Article 13(2) (329)
Article 13(3) (54)
Article 14 (36)
Article 15 (65)
Article 16 (77)
Article 17 (24)
Article 18 (12)
Article 19 (50)
Article 20 (97)
Article 21 (40)
Article 22 (1)
Article 25 (3)
Article 26 (60)
Article 27 (4)
Article 29 (10)
Article 30 (5)
Article 31 (2)
Article 35 (4)
Advanced options
Order:
Choose
CJEU - Preliminary ruling issued, case remitted to national courts (2)
Case remitted to lower court (17)
ECrtHR - Violation of Article 8 ECHR, award of damages (13)
Guidance on the application of the Convention issued (2)
Return ordered (221)
Return ordered with undertakings offered (22)
Return ordered subject to undertakings (23)
Return refused (114)
Application dismissed (86)
Appeal allowed, return ordered (97)
Appeal allowed, return ordered with undertakings offered (5)
Appeal allowed, return ordered subject to undertakings (5)
Appeal allowed, return refused (75)
Appeal dismissed, return ordered (219)
Appeal dismissed, return ordered with undertakings offered (7)
Appeal dismissed, return ordered subject to undertakings (4)
Appeal dismissed, return refused (100)
Appeal allowed, application dismissed (19)
Appeal dismissed, application dismissed (36)
Article 15 declaration granted (15)
Article 15 declaration refused (6)
Appeal dismissed, granting of Article 15 declaration confirmed (4)
Appeal dismissed, refusal of Article 15 declaration confirmed (2)
Appeal allowed, refusal of Article 15 declaration overturned (2)
Requesting State:
Choose
ALBANIA (2)
ARGENTINA (13)
ARMENIA (1)
AUSTRALIA (102)
AUSTRIA (4)
BELGIUM (21)
BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA (2)
BRAZIL (5)
BULGARIA (2)
BURKINA FASO (1)
CANADA (74)
CANADA - BRITISH COLUMBIA (1)
CANADA - ONTARIO (1)
CANADA - QUEBEC (2)
CHILE (13)
CHINA (HONG KONG, SAR) (4)
COLOMBIA (4)
COSTA RICA (2)
CROATIA (3)
CYPRUS (7)
CZECH REPUBLIC (3)
DENMARK (4)
ECUADOR (2)
EL SALVADOR (2)
ESTONIA (1)
FIJI (1)
FINLAND (7)
FRANCE (79)
GERMANY (89)
GREECE (26)
GUATEMALA (3)
HONDURAS (1)
HUNGARY (14)
ICELAND (1)
INDIA (1)
IRELAND (20)
ISRAEL (58)
ITALY (67)
JAPAN (4)
LATVIA (1)
LEBANON (1)
LITHUANIA (4)
LUXEMBOURG (3)
MALTA (2)
MAURITIUS (4)
MEXICO (34)
MONACO (1)
MONTENEGRO (2)
MOROCCO (3)
MOZAMBIQUE (1)
NETHERLANDS - KINGDOM IN EUROPE (20)
NEW ZEALAND (25)
NICARAGUA (1)
NIGERIA (1)
NORWAY (15)
PAKISTAN (1)
PARAGUAY (4)
PERU (3)
PHILIPPINES (1)
POLAND (20)
PORTUGAL (21)
ROMANIA (6)
RUSSIAN FEDERATION (3)
SAUDI ARABIA (2)
SERBIA (2)
SINGAPORE (6)
SLOVAKIA (4)
SOUTH AFRICA (15)
SPAIN (72)
SRI LANKA (1)
SUDAN (1)
SWEDEN (21)
SWITZERLAND (18)
THAILAND (1)
TURKEY (7)
UKRAINE (4)
UNITED ARAB EMIRATES (2)
UNITED KINGDOM (41)
UNITED KINGDOM - ENGLAND AND WALES (92)
UNITED KINGDOM - NORTHERN IRELAND (3)
UNITED KINGDOM - SCOTLAND (12)
UNITED STATES - FEDERAL JURISDICTION (4)
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA (292)
UNITED STATES - STATE JURISDICTION (1)
URUGUAY (1)
VENEZUELA (10)
ZIMBABWE (3)
Requested State:
Choose
ARGENTINA (14)
AUSTRALIA (78)
AUSTRIA (59)
BANGLADESH (1)
BELGIUM (17)
BRAZIL (4)
CAMEROON (3)
CANADA (97)
CANADA - ALBERTA (1)
CANADA - BRITISH COLUMBIA (5)
CANADA - MANITOBA (5)
CANADA - NEW BRUNSWICK (1)
CANADA - NOVA SCOTIA (1)
CANADA - ONTARIO (13)
CANADA - QUEBEC (9)
CANADA - SASKATCHEWAN (1)
CHILE (3)
CHINA (HONG KONG, SAR) (10)
CHINA (MAINLAND), PEOPLE'S RECPUBLIC OF (1)
COLOMBIA (1)
COSTA RICA (3)
CROATIA (7)
CYPRUS (1)
CZECH REPUBLIC (5)
DENMARK (17)
DOMINICAN REPUBLIC (2)
ECUADOR (1)
EL SALVADOR (3)
ESTONIA (2)
FINLAND (10)
FRANCE (130)
FRANCE (Reunion) (1)
GEORGIA (4)
GERMANY (58)
GREECE (10)
GUATEMALA (1)
HUNGARY (4)
ICELAND (5)
INDIA (1)
IRELAND (22)
ISRAEL (41)
ITALY (20)
JAMAICA (1)
JAPAN (18)
KENYA (1)
KOREA, REPUBLIC OF (1)
LATVIA (3)
LITHUANIA (2)
LUXEMBOURG (17)
MALTA (2)
MEXICO (3)
MONACO (1)
NETHERLANDS - KINGDOM IN EUROPE (10)
NEW ZEALAND (53)
NICARAGUA (1)
NORWAY (6)
PAKISTAN (2)
PANAMA (5)
PARAGUAY (4)
PERU (3)
POLAND (11)
PORTUGAL (5)
ROMANIA (9)
RUSSIAN FEDERATION (4)
SAMOA (1)
SINGAPORE (1)
SLOVAKIA (4)
SLOVENIA (1)
SOUTH AFRICA (22)
SPAIN (10)
SWEDEN (7)
SWITZERLAND (95)
TRINIDAD AND TOBAGO (1)
TURKEY (12)
UKRAINE (2)
UNITED KINGDOM (2)
UNITED KINGDOM - ENGLAND AND WALES (187)
UNITED KINGDOM - NORTHERN IRELAND (11)
UNITED KINGDOM - SCOTLAND (53)
UNITED STATES - FEDERAL JURISDICTION (91)
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA (68)
UNITED STATES - STATE JURISDICTION (35)
URUGUAY (8)
VENEZUELA (1)
ZIMBABWE (1)
Court level:
Choose
Inter-American Court on Human Rights (1)
Superior Appellate Court (320)
Appellate Court (538)
First Instance (497)
European Court of Human Rights (ECrtHR) (69)
Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (1)
Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) (12)
Other (5)
Instrument:
Non-Hague Convention
(39)
Brussels II bis
(86)
Inter-American Convention
(7)
Search
