Refine your search

Keyword:

Grounds:

Show more

Year:

Country:

Show more

Article(s):

Show more

Order:

Show more

Requesting State:

Show more

Requested State:

Show more

Court Level:

Show more

Instrument:

Search results (1632)

  • 2018 | HC/E/JP 1388 | JAPAN | Superior Appellate Court
    Languages
    Full text download JA | EN
    Summary available in EN | ES
    Grounds

    Non-Convention Issues | Issues Relating to Return

    Order

    Case remitted to lower court

    Synopsis

    1 child wrongfully removed at age 11 years and 3 months ― National of Japan and the United States ― Married parents ― Father and mother nationals of Japan ― Father was granted sole custody by a court in the United States after the return order became final and binding ― Child lived in the United States until 12 January 2016 ― Application for return filed with the courts of Japan in July 2016 ― Return ordered and execution by substitute failed (due to the mother’s strenuous resistance and the child’s objection); the father subsequently filed a request for habeas corpus relief ― Main issues: Non-Convention Issues, Issues Relating to Return ― There are special circumstances in which a mature child cannot be seen to be staying with the abducting parent based on his free will, so continued care of the child in defiance of a return order can amount to “restraint” under the Habeas Corpus Act and Habeas Corpus Rules ― Where continued “restraint” by the abducting parent in breach of a return order is “conspicuously illegal”, the requirements of a habeas corpus order are met.

  • 2016 | HC/E/HR 1392 | CROATIA | First Instance
    Languages
    No full text available
    Summary available in EN | ES
    Grounds

    Rights of Custody - Art. 3 | Grave Risk - Art. 13(1)(b) | Objections of the Child to a Return - Art. 13(2) | Issues Relating to Return | Procedural Matters

    Order

    Return refused

    Article(s)

    7 12 13(1)(b) 13(2) 16 19

    Synopsis

    1 child wrongfully retained at age 5 – National of Croatia and Germany – Married parents– Father national of Croatia and Germany – Mother national of Croatia – Joint parental responsibility  according to the German Civil Code – Child lived in Germany until December 2015 – Application for return filed with the Central Authority of Croatia on 22 March 2016 – Application for return filed with the courts of Croatia on 30 May 2016 – Return refused – Main issues: Art. 13(1)(b) grave risk exception to return, Objections of the Child to a Return, Procedural matters  – The Court refused the request for return of the child under Art. 13(1)(b) of the 1980 Hague Child Abduction Convention.

  • 2021 | HC/E/AR 1588 | ARGENTINA | First Instance
    Languages
    Full text download ES
    Summary available in EN | ES
    Grounds

    Inter-American Convention on the International Return of Children

    Order

    Return refused

    Article(s)

    13(1)(b) 13(2) 20

    Synopsis

    Wrongful removal of three girls when they were 15, 10 and 7 years old - Paraguayan – married parents – Paraguayan father – Paraguayan mother – the girls lived in Paraguay until October 2018 – the return request was filed before the Paraguayan Central Authority – return refused – main issues: grave risk, human rights, procedural matters, best interest of the child – returned exposed the girls to a true risk of suffering psychological and physical harm, since they were victims of their father’s violence, as well as their mother was – return would amount to a violation of their dignity due to the violence exerted by their father – considering that the mother had returned to Paraguay, the maternal grandmother was given provisional care for a 90-day period until the girls returned to Paraguay with their mother

  • 2017 | HC/E/FR 1719 | FRANCE | Superior Appellate Court
    Languages
    Full text download FR
    Summary available in EN
    Grounds

    Removal and Retention - Arts 3 and 12

    Order

    Appeal dismissed, return refused

    Article(s)

    3 12

    Synopsis

    3 children allegedly wrongfully removed – Both parents have custody rights – Children lived in Sweden from 2014 to February 2016 – Application for return filed by the public prosecutor with a court in France on 14 June 2016 – Return refused at first instance and upheld on appeal – Main issue: Art. 3 Wrongful removal – There was an existing agreement between the parents for the permanent relocation of the children to France, making their removal not wrongful.

  • 2012 | HC/E/LU 696 | LUXEMBOURG | Appellate Court |
    Languages
    Full text download FR
    Summary available in FR
    Grounds

    Grave Risk - Art. 13(1)(b) | Issues Relating to Return | Procedural Matters

    Article(s)

    3 13(1)(b)

  • 2022 | HC/E/FR 1728 | FRANCE | Superior Appellate Court
    Languages
    Full text download FR
    Summary available in EN
    Grounds

    Grave Risk - Art. 13(1)(b)

    Order

    Case remitted to lower court

    Article(s)

    13(1)(b)

    Synopsis

    1 child wrongfully removed at 2 years old – Father national of Spain – Mother national of France – Both parents have rights of custody over the child – Child lived in Spain until 12 August 2020 – Application for return filed on 5 November 2020 – Return refused at first instance - Decision affirmed on appeal – Supreme Court overturned appeal decision and remitted to a lower court - Main issue: Art. 13(1)(b) Grave Risk – The Supreme Court found that the Court of Appeal did not provide a sufficient legal basis for its decision that a return to Spain would establish a grave risk for the child.

  • 2023 | HC/E/MX 1687 | MEXICO | Superior Appellate Court
    Languages
    Full text download ES
    Summary available in EN | ES
    Grounds

    Grave Risk - Art. 13(1)(b) | Objections of the Child to a Return - Art. 13(2) | Procedural Matters

    Order

    Case remitted to lower court

    Article(s)

    13(1)(b) 13(2)

    Synopsis

    Child born in 2016 in Mexico – habitual residence in the United States of America – wrongful retention – Main issues: grave risk (Art. 13(1)(b)) – domestic violence – child’s objections to return – procedural matters – appeal allowed – case remitted to the court of first instance.

  • 2021 | HC/E/UKe 1509 | UNITED KINGDOM - ENGLAND AND WALES | Superior Appellate Court
    Languages
    Full text download EN
    Summary available in EN
    Grounds

    Non-Convention Issues | Grave Risk - Art. 13(1)(b)

    Order

    Appeal allowed, return refused

    Article(s)

    2 13(1)(b) 13(2)

    Ruling

    The Court refused to order the return of the child until the mother's asylum application had been determined.

  • 2022 | HC/E/UKe 1734 | UNITED KINGDOM - ENGLAND AND WALES | First Instance
    Languages
    Full text download EN
    Summary available in EN
    Grounds

    Grave Risk - Art. 13(1)(b) | Objections of the Child to a Return - Art. 13(2)

    Order

    Return ordered

    Article(s)

    3 13(1)(b) 13(2)

    Synopsis

    Two children wrongfully removed at ages 6 and 10  – Children were living with the grandmother in Portugal until the mother’s death and before their removal to the UK, grandmother had rights of custody – Children lived in Portugal until 21 July 2021  – Application for return filed with the Central Authority of Portugal on 13 September 2021  – Return ordered – Main issues: Article 13(1)(b), a return to Portugal would have an adverse psychological impact on the children but this would not create a grave risk - Child’s Objections, the elder child had a preference to remain in the United Kingdom but this did not amount to an objection within the meaning of Article 13(2). 

  • 2025 | HC/E/UKe 1607 | UNITED KINGDOM - ENGLAND AND WALES | First Instance
    Languages
    Full text download EN
    Summary available in EN
    Grounds

    Grave Risk - Art. 13(1)(b) | Undertakings | Objections of the Child to a Return - Art. 13(2) | Non-Convention Issues

    Order

    Return refused

    Article(s)

    13(1)(b) 13(2)

    Synopsis

    Three children, 8-year-old boy (D), 6-year-old boy (Y) and 3-year-old girl (B), wrongfully removed - Parents divorced - Father national of Sudan - Mother national of Sudan - D and Y born in Egypt - B born in the Netherlands - Children subject to supervision order in the Netherlands, primarily cared for by the mother with the father allowed contact - Family lived in the Netherlands from 2020 until 2023 - Mother made serious allegations of domestic abuse against the father, including rape, beatings of her and the children, and a desire for B to undergo FGM - Mother wrongfully removed the children from the Netherlands on 6 or 7 July 2023, travelling by small boat to the UK - Father filed application for return with the High Court of England and Wales on 13 June 2024 - Return refused - Main issues: Article 13(b) - Domestic abuse allegations so severe that the risk of return was grave - Undertakings offered by the father were inadequate to be sufficient protective measures - D and Y opposed return but this did not constitute an objection for Article 13 purposes.

  • 2023 | HC/E/UKe 1703 | UNITED KINGDOM - ENGLAND AND WALES | First Instance
    Languages
    Full text download EN
    Summary available in EN
    Grounds

    Objections of the Child to a Return - Art. 13(2) | Grave Risk - Art. 13(1)(b) | Aims of the Convention - Preamble, Arts 1 and 2

    Order

    Return ordered

    Article(s)

    13(1)(b) 13(2)

    Ruling

    Return ordered. The children’s objections and Article 13(1)(b) exceptions to return were not established. Any welfare issues must be resolved by the home court in the Republic of Ireland. 

  • 2021 | HC/E/UKe 1664 | UNITED KINGDOM - ENGLAND AND WALES | Appellate Court
    Languages
    Full text download EN
    Summary available in EN
    Grounds

    Acquiescence - Art. 13(1)(a) | Grave Risk - Art. 13(1)(b)

    Order

    Appeal allowed, return refused

    Article(s)

    13(1)(a) 13(1)(b)

    Ruling

    Appeal allowed, return refused. The first instance judge had erred in her approach to determining whether there was a grave risk to the children under Article 13(1)(b).

  • 2025 | HC/E/UKe 1692 | UNITED KINGDOM - ENGLAND AND WALES | First Instance
    Languages
    Full text download EN
    Summary available in EN
    Grounds

    Grave Risk - Art. 13(1)(b)

    Order

    Return refused

    Article(s)

    13(1)(b)

    Ruling

    Return refused. Given the mother's vulnerable situation, a return to Spain would risk exposing the child to physical or psychological harm, or otherwise place her in an intolerable situation.

  • 2024 | HC/E/UKe 1612 | UNITED KINGDOM - ENGLAND AND WALES | Appellate Court
    Languages
    Full text download EN
    Summary available in EN
    Grounds

    Acquiescence - Art. 13(1)(a) | Grave Risk - Art. 13(1)(b)

    Order

    Appeal dismissed, return refused

    Article(s)

    13(1)(a) 13(1)(b)

    Ruling

    Appeal dismissed.

  • 2023 | HC/E/UKe 1699 | UNITED KINGDOM - ENGLAND AND WALES | First Instance
    Languages
    Full text download EN
    Summary available in EN
    Grounds

    Grave Risk - Art. 13(1)(b)

    Order

    Return ordered

    Article(s)

    13(1)(b)

    Ruling

    Return ordered. Whilst the Mother established that there was a grave risk of harm to the child within the meaning of Article 13(1)(b), the protective measures available in Slovakia and the undertakings offered by the Father were more than sufficient to protect him.

  • 2022 | HC/E/UKe 1735 | UNITED KINGDOM - ENGLAND AND WALES | First Instance
    Languages
    Full text download EN
    Summary available in EN
    Grounds

    Rights of Custody - Art. 3 | Grave Risk - Art. 13(1)(b)

    Order

    Return ordered

    Article(s)

    3 13(1)(b)

    Synopsis

    Three children wrongfully removed between the ages of 7 and 9 – Children lived with the father and stayed with the mother four days each fortnight – Chidren lived in Austria until August 2020  – Application for return filed on 1 September 2020 – Return ordered  – Main issues: The removal was wrongful under Article 3 and there was no grave risk of harm within the meaning of Article 13(1)(b). 

  • 2021 | HC/E/UKe 1740 | UNITED KINGDOM - ENGLAND AND WALES | First Instance
    Languages
    Full text download EN
    Summary available in EN
    Grounds

    Rights of Custody - Art. 3 | Grave Risk - Art. 13(1)(b) | Non-Convention Issues

    Order

    Return ordered with undertakings offered

    Article(s)

    3 13(1)(b)

    Synopsis

    Two children wrongfully removed, both age 6 – Unmarried parents – Father national of Ireland – Mother national of United Kingdom – Joint custody – Children lived in Ireland until September 2020 – Return ordered – Main issue: Article 3, father had rights of custody under Irish law; Article 13(1)(b), there was no grave risk of harm to the children on return to Ireland; Non-Convention issues, a relocation order was made with regard to the mother’s child with a new partner. 

  • 2025 | HC/E/ES 1743 | SPAIN | Appellate Court
    Languages
    Full text download ES
    Summary available in ES
    Grounds

    Removal and Retention - Arts 3 and 12 | Grave Risk - Art. 13(1)(b) | Settlement of the Child - Art. 12(2)

    Order

    Appeal allowed, return refused

    Article(s)

    3 12 13(1)(b)

  • 2026 | HC/E/US 1754 | UNITED STATES OF AMERICA | First Instance
    Languages
    Full text download EN
    Summary available in EN
    Grounds

    Grave Risk - Art. 13(1)(b) | Consent - Art. 13(1)(a) | Acquiescence - Art. 13(1)(a)

    Order

    Return ordered

    Article(s)

    13(1)(a) 13(1)(b)

    Synopsis

    One child wrongfully retained at age 1 – National of Turkey – Married parents – Father national of Turkey – Mother national of Turkey – Joint custody – Child lived in Turkey until 2024  – Application for return submitted to the Turkish Ministry of Justice in November 2024 and filed with the federal district court for the Northern District of Georgia in July 2025 – Return ordered – Main issues: Article 13(1)(b): there was no clear and convincing evidence that the child would be subjected to such a risk and the alleged violence was not repeated abuse but isolated incidents. Article 13(1)(a) Consent: it was clear that the father consented only to a temporary visit. Article 13(1)(a) Acquiescence: the father’s efforts to remain in the child’s life did not amount to acquiescence. 

  • 2025 | HC/E/AR 1737 | ARGENTINA | Superior Appellate Court
    Languages
    Full text download ES
    Summary available in EN | ES
    Grounds

    Procedural Matters | Issues Relating to Return

    Order

    Return ordered

    Article(s)

    13(1)(b)

    Synopsis

    Two children, ages 8 and 6—nationals of the Russian Federation—divorced parents—Russian father—Russian mother—habitual residence with the mother in Moscow until March 2022—wrongful removal—the request for return was filed through the Russian Central Authority in 2024—return ordered—Main issues: procedural issues; issues relating to the child’s return – Appeal denied – The request for recognition of refugee status and protection under the principle of non-refoulement did not justify a stay of the return proceedings and could be assessed at the enforcement stage – The return was to be immediate and safe and carried out under conditions that would be least harmful to the children.