AFFAIRE

Télécharger le texte complet EN

Nom de l'affaire

Re BS (A Child) (Child Abduction) [2021] EWHC 2643 (Fam)

Référence INCADAT

HC/E/UKe 1738

Juridiction

Pays

Royaume-Uni - Angleterre et Pays de Galles

Degré

Première instance

États concernés

État requérant

Italie

État requis

Royaume-Uni - Angleterre et Pays de Galles

Décision

Date

14 September 2021

Statut

Définitif

Motifs

Risque grave - art. 13(1)(b)

Décision

Retour ordonné avec des engagements proposés

Article(s) de la Convention visé(s)

13(1)(a) 13(1)(b)

Article(s) de la Convention visé(s) par le dispositif

-

Autres dispositions

Guide to Good Practice on Article 13(1)(b) of the 1980 Convention

Jurisprudence | Affaires invoquées

-

Publiée dans

-

SYNOPSIS

Synopsis disponible en EN

1 child wrongfully removed at age 6 – National of Italy and Brazil  – Married parents – Father national of Italy – Mother national of Italy and Brazil – Joint custody – Child lived in Italy until 28 February 2021  – Return ordered – Main issue: Article 13(1)(b) not made out, it was unlikely that the mother and child would be separated and there was no evidence of abuse by the father. 

RÉSUMÉ

Résumé disponible en EN

Facts

The parents met in Brazil in 2000 and married in Italy the same year. They lived in Italy and had a child, born in 2014, age 6 at the time of the hearing. The father was an Italian national and the mother and child were dual Italian-Brazilian nationals. 

In February 2021 the mother took the child to the UK without the father’s knowledge. The father raised this with the Italian authorities later the same day. 

The father filed an application under the 1980 Hague Abduction Convention for the return of the child to Italy.

The mother argued that Article 13(1)(b) applied and that returning the child to Italy would mean she is separated from her mother and so place her in an intolerable situation.

Ruling

Return ordered. Article 13(1)(b) was not made out, it was unlikely that the mother and child would be separated and there was no evidence of abuse by the father. 

Grounds

Grave Risk - Art. 13(1)(b)

The mother said she would likely be arrested on return to Italy and that the father had applied for an order to suspend her parental rights. She argued that this would mean the child would be separated from her and put in an intolerable situation.

The Judge dismissed these arguments as separation of the mother and cild was unlikely and the father had offered not to support any criminal prosecution. Furthermore, there was no evidence of physical or emotional abuse by the father and any financial difficulties on return would be covered in the short term by the father’s undertakings.

The judgment referred to the Guide to Good Practice on Article 13(1)(b) of the 1980 Convention.