CASO

Descargar texto completo EN

Nombre del caso

Re A (A Child: Article 13(b): Mental Health) [2026] EWCA Civ 1090

Referencia INCADAT

HC/E/UKe 1764

Tribunal

País

Reino Unido - Inglaterra y Gales

Instancia

Tribunal de Apelaciones

Estados involucrados

Estado requirente

Australia

Estado requerido

Reino Unido - Inglaterra y Gales

Fallo

Fecha

14 August 2026

Estado

Definitiva

Fundamentos

Grave riesgo - art. 13(1)(b)

Fallo

Apelación desestimada, restitución ordenada

Artículo(s) del Convenio considerados

13(1)(b)

Artículo(s) del Convenio invocados en la decisión

-

Otras disposiciones

Guide to Good Practice on Article 13(1)(b) of the 1980 Convention

Jurisprudencia | Casos referidos

-

Publicado en

-

SINOPSIS

Sinopsis disponible en EN

1 child wrongfully retained at age 4 – Father national of Australia – Mother national of UK – Joint custody – Child lived in Australia until February 2025 – Application for return filed in February 2026 – Return ordered – Main issue: Article 13(1)(b),  the allegations of domestic violence did not reach the grave risk threshold and that, though there would be a “virtually inevitable” impact on the mother’s mental health, she would be able to access support in Australia. 

SUMARIO

Sumario disponible en EN

Facts

The mother was born in the UK and moved to Australia in 2010. The father was an Australian citizen. The mother was a UK citizen and naturalised Australian citizen. 

The parents met in Australia in 2020 and had a child there in 2021. In February 2025 the mother travelled with the child to the UK to visit the maternal grandparents. The visit became increasingly prolonged and, in September 2025, the mother enrolled the child in a local school against the father’s wishes. 

In February 2026 the father made an application under the 1980 Hague Abduction Convention for the return of the child. 

The mother argued that Article 13(1)(b) applied and that returning the child to Australia would  expose him to grave physical or psychological harm or would otherwise place him in an intolerable situation. She relied on allegations of domestic abuse, the risk to her mental health if forced to return to Australia and the impact that would have on the child.

At first instance the Judge ordered the return of the child to Australia. The mother appealed the decision. 

Ruling

Appeal dismissed, return ordered. 

Grounds

Grave Risk - Art. 13(1)(b)

The mother also alleged that the father was controlling and had been emotionally, financially and sexually coercive. She also said that a return would be “catastrophic” for her mental health as there would be no one to care for her parents in the UK.

The father denied the allegations of domestic violence or coercion. He expressed sympathy for the mother’s situation, but stated that the child’s home was in Australia and that alternative care arrangements could be made for her parents.

At first instance, the judge found that the allegations of domestic violence did not reach the grave risk threshold and that, though there would be a “virtually inevitable” impact on the mother’s mental health, she would be able to access support in Australia. 

The Court of Appeal held that the first instance judge was entitled to reach this conclusion. 

The judgment referred to the Guide to Good Practice on Article 13(1)(b) of the 1980 Convention.